The 11 Best Alcohol Bottles in 2021

This was an exceptional year for new releases of spirits in all categories, and so it was an exceptional year for drinking. It’s impossible to cover them all, but here are the best of the best, based on alcohol alone, including whiskey, tequila, gin, rum, and cognac. Some are easy to come by, while others are expensive and elusive limited editions. But if a spirit tasted good, it made the list—hype, price, and reputation be damned. See if you can find a few of these to try for yourself before the end of 2019, and here’s to another year (and decade) of good spirits.


 Four Roses Small Batch Select

Four Roses consistently knocks it out of the park with its core range, a lineup of dependable bourbon that could be more expensive than it is but usually isn’t (please don’t raise your prices, Four Roses). The new Small Batch Select is sort of further refining of the Small Batch expression, a blend of bourbon aged for at least six years using six of the distillery’s 10 different recipes. The ABV is higher too, at 104 proof, and the whiskey is non-chill filtered. Expect a velvety mouthfeel and notes of cherry, oak, and vanilla, making this a welcome—and permanent—addition to the portfolio.


Baker’s Single Barrel Bourbon

It can be difficult to pick a single barrel bourbon for a best-of list, given that each barrel will be somewhat different. But the move by the underrated Baker’s Bourbon (part of the Jim Beam Small Batch collection) to a 7-year-old single-barrel release was a smart one. At 107 proof, the whiskey retains all of the signature Jim Beam nut and grain-forward flavors, along with warmth and a complex bouquet of fruit notes. If you can get your hands on a pair of bottles from different barrels, see for yourself how the flavors compare and contrast.

Bardstown Bourbon Company Goodwood Brewing Company Honey Ale

Admittedly, this is not the most readily available bourbon out there, as it’s a limited regional release. But it’s a damn good one, and works in a way that barrel finishes sometimes don’t. Bardstown Bourbon Company sourced this 11-year-old bourbon from Indiana and finished it in Louisville’s Goodwood Brewing Brandy Barrel Honey Ale casks for about a year and a half, infusing the liquid with rich but not overpowering notes of honey, quince, and vanilla. The two will collaborate again in 2020 with a bourbon finished in Walnut Brown Ale casks, so it will be interesting to see how that compares.


Wild Turkey Master’s Keep Cornerstone Rye

It’s hard to beat regular old Wild Turkey; the high quality and low price of the distillery’s bourbon and rye make it an American classic. The distillery has also released several high-end whiskeys over the past few years as part of its Master’s Keep series. The latest is this expensive but excellent rye whiskey aged for 9 to 11 years and bottled at 109 proof. Think of it as a fancier Russell’s Reserve, and enjoy the spice, pepper, and oak note that pop with every sip.


Old Forester Rye

A good piece of whiskey news for your palate and your wallet this past year was the release of Old Forester Rye, a new addition to the range and the first new recipe from the distillery in a century and a half. The mash bill is 65 percent rye, 20 percent malted barley, and 15 percent corn, softening some of the spice but keeping the floral notes. The high malt component allowed for a “wholly natural fermentation process,” according to master distiller Chris Morris. The whiskey is bottled at 100 proof, making this a great one to use in cocktails as well.


Michter’s 10 Year Single Barrel Rye

Yes, this is another expensive whiskey, and one that is probably selling for way more than its SRP. But it’s also fantastic, as Michter’s annual release always tends to be. This was the first of this type of whiskey to be released under the watch of new Michter’s master distiller Dan McKee, and he did a great job selecting the barrels for it. The whiskey is spicy, sweet, and full of toffee and caramel. Save it for a special occasion, if you can get your hands on a bottle.

Chattanooga Whiskey CASK 111

This delicious Tennessee whiskey from Chattanooga Whiskey has an interesting mash bill made up of yellow corn and three kinds of specialty malt—malted rye, caramel malted barley, and honey malted barley. This is the cask strength, unfiltered version of the distillery’s Whiskey 91. It’s aged for around two years, but tastes like a whiskey that’s twice as old. There’s a pronounced maltiness, as you might expect, but also warm notes of stone fruit and chocolate.

Wyoming Whiskey Outryder

Wyoming Whiskey has been making good, solid whiskey for years now, something that got the attention of Scottish company Edrington (owner of The Macallan), which added the brand to its portfolio in 2018. Outryder is a bottled-in-bond whiskey that combines two mash bills—a high rye whiskey and a traditional bourbon. It’s aged for seven years and hits all the right notes with banana, cinnamon, and some yeasty bread on the palate.

Westland Garryana Edition 4|1

Westland is a Seattle distillery that is doing interesting things in the world of American single malts, like the fourth edition of this whiskey that is all about showcasing the influence of Quercus garryana oak on the spirit. The liquid was matured in a number of other casks as well, including rye, bourbon, and sherry barrels for a range of 44 to 75 months. The result is a particularly fruity single malt that should appeal to those who are interested in the burgeoning American single malt category.


The GlenDronach Cask Strength Batch 8

Fans of sherry cask single malts like The Macallan and Aberlour should definitely be on the lookout for The GlenDronach, particularly this new, cask strength version of the whisky. It spent 10 years in PX and Oloroso sherry casks before being bottled at 122 proof, which provides some nice heat and spice to the sweet notes of dried fruit and fig. This is the eighth batch of the cask strength expression, which is non-chill filtered with no color added.


Laphroaig 16 Year Old

Most people are familiar with Laphroaig as that peaty scotch that curls as many lips as it brings smiles to. This new expression spends six more years in ex-bourbon barrels than the core 10-year-old, a time difference that yields big results. The salty, medicinal peat smoke is still there, of course, but alongside a greater infusion of vanilla, fruit, and oak. This is a limited release for the time being, but will become part of the core range in the coming months.